Play it again, and again….
Yes it gets boring, but it's been a steady gig for three castmembers
of ‘Phantom' who've been there from the start.
Segal -Washington Post
New York- sometimes he forgets his lines. It doesn’t happen often,
but now and again George Lee Andrews will be singing of gamboling onstage
at the Majestic Theatre, in front of a crowd of 1,600, and he will simply
go bland. He’ll hunt, but it’s like the words are dressed
in camouflage and hiding in the jungle.
“Oh, I’ve had some legendary moments,” chuckles Andrews,
sitting in his dressing room one recent evening.
It’s the kind of flop-sweat terror every Broadway actor know.
But Andrews is not just any Broadway actor. He’s a cast member
of “The Phantom of the Opera,” a musical that is less than
a week away from setting a record as the longest-running production in
Broadway history. After a special gala performance on Monday, “Phantom” will
have been performed 7,486 times, one more than “Cats” which
closed five years ago. (“The Fantastics,” which was staged
more than 17,000 times, doesn’t count in this derby because it
was an off-Broadway show, which means it ran in a theater with fewer
than 500 seats.)
Here’s the staggering part: Andrews has been in the show, continuously,
since opining night. When “Cats” closed there wasn’t
a single actor who’d been in the production from the start. *****(NOTE
FROM DODIE; this is not true. This reporter didn’t do his homework.
Marlene Danielle did the entire run of “Cats”. I know – I
“Phantom has three: Andrews, Richard Warren Pugh and Mary Leigh
Stahl. Excluding sick leave, this trio has been rehashing the same story
about the same half-masked freak in the same hokey extravaganza eight
times a week, for 18 consecutive years.
Imagine it. Eighteen years of Andrew Lloyd Webber’s Nutra-Sweet
score, a hybrid that suggests Puccini as rendered by a flock of Seagulls.
Plus numbingly sentimental lyrics, courtesy of Charles Hart and Richard
Stilgoe. It’s the sort of punishment that the Geneva Conventions
were supposed to ban, isn’t it? But the math doesn’t lie.
Tally up the actual stage time, excluding rehearsals. And each of the
three actors has spent 750 24-hour days more than two years of their
respective lives performing “Phantom.”
“People ask me if I get bored,” says Andrews, who seems
the opposite of aggrieved and rarely stops smiling. “That’s
not really an issue for me.”
Everybody knew “The Phantom of the Opera,” an adaptation
of the novel by Gaston Leroux, would be a hit when it opened here in
1988. The original, in London, was a phenomenon, and the show opened
in Manhattan with a record$18 million in advance ticket sales.
Reviews were generally positive, and the production eventually won seven
Tony Awards, including best musical.
But there are hit and there are Hits. With worldwide box office receipts
or more than $3.2 billion, “Phantom” is now the highest-grossing
entertainment venture in history – dwarfing the$1.8 billion earned
by “Titanic.” According to the show’s public relation
office, more than 80 million people around the world have seen “Phantom” either
in one of the six permanent productions scattered from Budapest to Tokyo
or in the U.S. road version, which has for years been crisscrossing the
country. Another version is set to open at the Venetian Hotel in Las
The show’s director, Harold Prince, thinks the atmosphere of fantasy
is key to its success.
“It’s far removed from the loves that people live outside
the theater,” he said by phone last week. “It’s like
a kid coming to a magic show. Everyone leaves their troubles behind,
and you enter this world that is mysterious and glamorous and exotic.”
The movie version, released in 2004, certainly helped. It was a flop,
but the advertising campaign used the same imagery and music. Like everything
else on Broadway, the show took a beating after 9/11 crushed the tourism
business. But “we just checked the grosses and 2005 will be our
best year ever,” says Alan Wasser, who manages the production.
The producers have built their latest ad campaign, billed as “Remember
Your First Time,” on the assumption that everyone on Earth has
sat through it already, and probably more than once. Hard-core Phans – as
they call themselves, naturally – have been to the show dozens
and sometimes hundreds of times and swamp chat rooms with minutiae and
The Majestic’s dressing room area feels surprisingly like a cabin
on a submarine. Everything is packed in close, every inch of space is
used, and before a show, everyone is scurrying to do a job they seem
to know by heart. You hear the tra-la-las of performers warming up. A
voice on a loudspeaker booms a countdown to curtain time and occasionally
the name of an actor.
“If you don’t sign in, they start calling your name on the
PA,” Andrews says in his dressing room. “Then they’ll
call your cell-phone. That happens to me when I’m at Starbucks.”
Andrews moved to New York City more than 30 years ago from Milwaukee,
starting his Broadway career in 1973 with “Jacques Brel Is Alive
and Well and Living in Paris.” For the last five years, he’s
played Monsieur Andre, his third part over these past 18 years.
Andrews appears to be the unofficial mayor of backstage Phantomville,
and its historian, too. He has kept track of the actors who pirouetted
through the play and then moved on – asking each for a headshot. “I
think there are something like 260 pictures down there now,” Andrews
According to the production office, come Monday, the Phantom at the
Majestic will have been shot at 14,972 times. Some 1.4 million gallons
of shot powder, needed for an assortment of flash pots, will have been
burned. And if you laid out end to end the pages of Playbills handed
to audience members since opening night you’d nave 43,105 miles
of paper, enough almost to circle the globe twice.
“We counted, and it’s over 700 steps per night,” say
Mary Leigh Stahl, who has the distinction of playing the same parts every
night for the 18-year run. “That included three trips to the dressing
room, which is on the fifth floor.”
For Stahl and the other 18-year veterans of the show, “Phantom” has
provided a lifestyle that is all but unheard of in the theater world.
“I don’t think I’d still be in New York if I hadn’t
gotten ‘Phantom ,’” Stahl said. “This isn’t
and easy business, especially for women. I feel like I hit the lottery.”
A sense of gratitude not to mention decorum might explain why you won’t
hear a primal scream of restive anguish from Andrews, Pugh or Stahl.
All three politely deflect every version of the question. Hey isn’t
this gig driving you bonkers? “It’s work, and this show has
been amazing to me,” says Pugh, who has played four parts during
The challenge is to locate the ideal mental state to recite the same
words for the 7,000th time. Total concentration, weirdly enough, has
If you’ve ever focused hard on a mundane task – like walking
down a flight of stairs, for instance – and screwed up as a result,
you know why. In the days after Andrews bitches a line, he tends to over-think
his dialogue in the show that follow.
“You’re running scare for a few performances,” he
says. “You’re running scared for a few performances,” he
says. “You’re thinking three steps ahead, which isn’t
But letting your mind wander is worse. Stahl say she’s taught
herself thing about a house she is going to remodel.
“I’m going to retire in eight months, to this place in Alabama,” she
says. “So I’ll be in the middle of the show thinking, ‘Maybe
I should get the kitchen floor redone.’”
The other challenge is trying to forget work when you’re not punched
in. That can be tricky, given that the original cast recording of “Phantom” spent
more than six years on the Billboard charts.
Pugh was honeymooning in Bermuda years ago, and piped over the loudspeakers
at a restaurant came ‘Music of the Night.”
“It was the first time I’d been away from the show in a
couple years,” he says. “ I told the waiter, ‘It’s
a lovely song. But here’s $10. Play something else.’”